It is not permissible for a Muslim caller in one country to criticise, attack and revile the Muslim Ruler of another country. By the Major Scholars of the Ummah: Salih al-Fawzan, Ibn ‘Uthaimeen and ‘Ubayd al-Jabiri

Question to al-ʿAllāmah, the noble scholar, Shaikh Sālih al-Fawzān (may Allāh preserve him):

“May Allāh grant you success, O noble Shaykh. This questioner asks: Is it permissible for a Muslim caller to Allāh, who is in a particular country, to speak about the Muslim ruler of another country?”

Answer: “No! He should instead propagate the creed of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamāʿah concerning those in authority and others, whether in the lands of disbelief or in the lands of the Muslims. This is an obligation upon the student of knowledge and an obligation upon every Muslim.”

Another question to al-ʿAllāmah, the noble scholar, Shaikh Sālih al-Fawzān (may Allāh preserve him):

“The Second Question: What advice can you give to those who criticise and speak disparagingly of certain countries and governments, from amongst the people of this land, whilst being people who love the rulers of this country?”

Answer: “By Allāh, as for discussing the affairs of certain countries and the policies of governments, a person is not charged with responsibility for these matters. Rather, what is incumbent upon him is to supplicate to Allāh on behalf of the Muslims, asking Him to rectify their affairs, set their condition right, and protect them from the evil of tribulations and the evil of their enemies.

As for mutual blame and mentioning the faults and shortcomings of countries and their rulers, this brings about no benefit. Rather, it leads to harm and an increase in evil.”

Question to al-ʿAllāmah, the noble scholar, Shaikh ʿUbayd al-Jābarī (may Allāh’s mercy be upon him):

“Some of the youth speak about rulers who are not their own rulers, but who govern other countries. When they are advised against this, they respond: “These rulers are not rulers over us.” How should we respond to them?”

Answer: “I heard this statement several months ago, attributed to one of our brothers in Najd, although, in reality, I have not investigated its authenticity. Whether it is authentically attributed to him or not, this is incorrect in the present age.

That is because there is no country except that it contains ignorant, uncouth people, driven by zeal and fervour. For this reason, I do not consider such conduct permissible, due to the harmful consequences that arise from it.

For example, if we were to insult or disparage a ruler in another country, an ignorant, insolent, oppressive and reckless individual would not hesitate to insult our rulers and incite people against them. He might even become involved with the Khawārij in their schemes and plots.

Preventing harm and warding off evil is an established Sharīʿah principle.

Yes, we have discussed this matter in detail on several occasions, including in ‘Taysīr al-Ilāh bi-Sharh Adillat Shurūt Lā Ilāha Illallāh’.”

A statement of al-ʿAllāmah, the noble scholar, Shaikh Muhammad Ibn Sālih al-ʿUthaimeen (may Allāh’s mercy be upon him):

“It is not permissible for us to speak publicly amongst the people in a manner that stirs up resentment against those in authority or causes people to despise them. For this entails tremendous harm.

A person may imagine that this is a manifestation of protective zeal and that he is openly proclaiming the truth. However, openly proclaiming the truth is not done from behind a veil. Rather, to speak the truth openly means that the ruler is before you, and you say to him: ‘You have done such-and-such, and this is impermissible. You have neglected such-and-such, whereas this is an obligation.’

As for speaking from behind a veil, insulting the ruler and publicly exposing his faults, this is not an act of openly proclaiming the truth. Rather, it is corruption. It is something that gives rise to resentment in people’s hearts, hatred towards those in authority and rebellion against them. It may even lead to something far graver: rising up against them and renouncing their pledge of allegiance – and Allāh’s refuge is sought. All of these are matters of which we must be acutely aware, and in dealing with them, we must adhere to the methodology followed by Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamāʿah.”

Speech of the Scholars